Camp Should-A-Been - Season 10.1

Camp Should-A-Been

This replay never happened. But it could have. While American Idol generated silly faux controversies at about the same rate that General Mills generates Cheerios, Camp Should-A-Been really had just one controversy to speak of in its first fifteen seasons. Back in 2011, everyone's prohibitive favorite to win the Season Ten replay was Haley Reinhart, who posted a growth trend through the roof and saved most of her best performances for last. Surely she'd have dispatched Scotty McCreery, Lauren Alaina and James Durbin with ease, right? Only problem was, Reinhart never made it past the Wild Card round. AI10 posted the highest-rated semifinals in WNTS history, and Reinhart's first performance was mediocre at best. By longstanding Camp rules, her Wild Card projected rating was based only on her performances to date, and thus out she went in a rather ignominious 15th place (Brett Lowenstein nipped her for 14th, to add insult to injury.) A few of her Idolsphere fans -- an, ahem, rather scary bunch -- were outraged that we didn't use her eventual 61.8 final rating as her baseline for that show, despite the fact that we'd never once done it that way. What if we had? Here's how the Season Ten Replay would have shaken out....

Results

Monday, June 20th, 2011

Top 24 Guys (Open)

Performance Web Rating Result
A House Is Not A Home0000A House Is Not A Home
90
 
2Safe
I Put A Spell On You0000I Put A Spell On You
88
 
2Safe
You've Got Another Thing Comin'0000You've Got Another Thing Comin'
83
 
2Safe
Maggie May0000Maggie May
70
 
2Safe
Letters From Home0000Letters From Home
65
 
2Safe
Light My Fire0000Light My Fire
47
 
5Wild Card
Just The Way You Are0000Just The Way You Are
43
 
5Wild Card
Angel0000Angel
38
 
7Eliminated
Superstition0000Superstition
35
 
7Eliminated
Streetcorner Symphony0000Streetcorner Symphony
27
 
7Eliminated
I'll Be0000I'll Be
25
 
7Eliminated
OMG0000OMG
5
 
7Eliminated
Tuesday, June 21st, 2011

Top 24 Girls (Open)

Performance Web Rating Result
I'll Stand By You0000I'll Stand By You
93
 
2Safe
Out Here On My Own0000Out Here On My Own
85
 
2Safe
Seven Day Fool0000Seven Day Fool
79
 
2Safe
Turn On The Radio0000Turn On The Radio
75
 
2Safe
Summertime0000Summertime
62
 
2Safe
Hero0000Hero
54
 
5Wild Card
Impossible0000Impossible
51
 
5Wild Card
Fallin'0000Fallin'
47
 
5Wild Card
Love All Over Me0000Love All Over Me
41
 
5Wild Card
Criminal0000Criminal
23
 
7Eliminated
Breakaway0000Breakaway
19
 
7Eliminated
Only Girl (In The World)0000Only Girl (In The World)
9
 
7Eliminated
Wednesday, June 22th, 2011

Wild Card (Open)

Performance Web Rating Result
I Need You Now0000I Need You Now
82
 
2Safe
Georgia On My Mind0000Georgia On My Mind
78
 
2Safe
I Believe In A Thing Called Love0000I Believe In A Thing Called Love
56
 
2Safe
Medley: Dominique / Sukiyaki / 99 Luftballons / Volare0000Medley: Dominique / Sukiyaki / 99 Luftballons / Volare
49
 
7Eliminated
Hair0000Hair
43
 
7Eliminated
And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going0000And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going
41
 
7Eliminated

The CSAB Final 13, Alternate Universe Dept:

  • Casey Abrams
  • Naima Adedapo
  • Lauren Alaina
  • Kendra Chantelle
  • James Durbin
  • Stefano Langone
  • Jacob Lusk
  • Scotty McCreery
  • Paul McDonald
  • Thia Megia
  • Haley Reinhart
  • Pia Toscano
  • Lauren Turner

Newcomers in italics. Failing to qualify: Ashthon Jones and Karen Rodriguez

Thursday, June 23rd, 2011

Final 13 (Personal Idol)

Performance Web Rating Result
All By Myself0000All By Myself
84
 
2Safe
Maybe I'm Amazed0000Maybe I'm Amazed
78
 
2Safe
If You Had My Love *0000If You Had My Love *
72
 
2Safe
With A Little Help From My Friends0000With A Little Help From My Friends
71
 
2Safe
The River0000The River
65
 
2Safe
I Believe I Can Fly0000I Believe I Can Fly
59
 
2Safe
Dream On *0000Dream On *
59
 
2Safe
Lately0000Lately
52
 
2Safe
Any Man Of Mine0000Any Man Of Mine
49
 
2Safe
Blue0000Blue
43
 
2Safe
Umbrella0000Umbrella
43
 
4Bottom Group
Come Pick Me Up0000Come Pick Me Up
41
 
4Bottom Group
Smile0000Smile
34
 
7Eliminated
Friday, June 24th, 2011

Final 12 (Year You Were Born)

Performance Web Rating Result
Where Do Broken Hearts Go0000Where Do Broken Hearts Go
78
 
2Safe
If You Don't Know Me By Now0000If You Don't Know Me By Now
75
 
2Safe
I'm The Only One0000I'm The Only One
69
 
2Safe
Walk Like An Egyptian *0000Walk Like An Egyptian *
65
 
2Safe
I'll Be There For You0000I'll Be There For You
62
 
2Safe
Every Rose Has Its Thorn *0000Every Rose Has Its Thorn *
53
 
2Safe
Can I Trust You With My Heart0000Can I Trust You With My Heart
49
 
2Safe
Alone0000Alone
47
 
2Safe
Smells Like Teen Spirit0000Smells Like Teen Spirit
39
 
2Safe
I'm Your Baby Tonight0000I'm Your Baby Tonight
31
 
4Bottom Group
I Guess That's Why They Call It The Blues0000I Guess That's Why They Call It The Blues
26
 
4Bottom Group
What's Love Got To Do With It0000What's Love Got To Do With It
14
 
7Eliminated
Saturday, June 25th, 2011

Final 11 (Motown)

Performance Web Rating Result
Living For The City0000Living For The City
84
 
2Safe
All In Love Is Fair0000All In Love Is Fair
75
 
2Safe
You're All I Need To Get By0000You're All I Need To Get By
72
 
2Safe
You Keep Me Hangin' On0000You Keep Me Hangin' On
70
 
2Safe
I Wish It Would Rain *0000I Wish It Would Rain *
59
 
2Safe
The Tracks Of My Tears0000The Tracks Of My Tears
54
 
2Safe
Quicksand *0000Quicksand *
48
 
2Safe
For Once In My Life0000For Once In My Life
48
 
2Safe
You Really Got A Hold On Me0000You Really Got A Hold On Me
47
 
4Bottom Group
I Heard It Through The Grapevine0000I Heard It Through The Grapevine
44
 
4Bottom Group
Hello0000Hello
26
 
7Eliminated
Sunday, June 26th, 2011

Final 10 (Elton John)

Performance Web Rating Result
Candle In The Wind0000Candle In The Wind
81
 
2Safe
Bennie And The Jets0000Bennie And The Jets
72
 
2Safe
Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting0000Saturday Night's Alright For Fighting
71
 
2Safe
Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me0000Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me
69
 
2Safe
Your Song0000Your Song
69
 
2Safe
Country Comfort0000Country Comfort
56
 
2Safe
Border Song *0000Border Song *
54
 
2Safe
Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word0000Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word
53
 
4Bottom Group
Tiny Dancer *0000Tiny Dancer *
44
 
4Bottom Group
Rocket Man0000Rocket Man
39
 
7Eliminated
Monday, June 27th, 2011

Final 9 (Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame)

Performance Web Rating Result
River Deep, Mountain High0000River Deep, Mountain High
86
 
2Safe
That's All Right0000That's All Right
73
 
2Safe
While My Guitar Gently Weeps0000While My Guitar Gently Weeps
72
 
2Safe
Have You Ever Seen The Rain0000Have You Ever Seen The Rain
65
 
2Safe
A Natural Woman0000A Natural Woman
62
 
2Safe
Piece Of My Heart0000Piece Of My Heart
57
 
2Safe
Tom Sawyer *0000Tom Sawyer *
49
 
4Bottom Group
Man In The Mirror0000Man In The Mirror
41
 
4Bottom Group
Colour My World *0000Colour My World *
40
 
7Eliminated

Tuesday, June 28th, 2011

Final 8 (Songs From The Movies)

Performance Web Rating Result
Let's All Go To The Lobby *0000Let's All Go To The Lobby *
73
 
2Safe
Heavy Metal0000Heavy Metal
71
 
2Safe
The Climb0000The Climb
63
 
2Safe
Call Me0000Call Me
47
 
2Safe
Cross My Heart0000Cross My Heart
47
 
2Safe
Bridge Over Troubled Water0000Bridge Over Troubled Water
45
 
4Bottom Group
I'd Like To Buy The World A Coke *0000I'd Like To Buy The World A Coke *
44
 
4Bottom Group
Nature Boy0000Nature Boy
37
 
7Eliminated
Wednesday, June 29th, 2011

Final 7 (21st Century)

Performance Web Rating Result
Rolling In The Deep0000Rolling In The Deep
77
 
2Safe
Uprising0000Uprising
72
 
2Safe
Mr. Brightside *0000Mr. Brightside *
67
 
2Safe
Born To Fly0000Born To Fly
60
 
2Safe
This Is War *0000This Is War *
40
 
4Bottom Group
Dance With My Father0000Dance With My Father
36
 
4Bottom Group
Swingin'0000Swingin'
27
 
7Eliminated
Thursday, June 30th, 2011

Final 6 (Carole King)

Performance Web Rating Result
Will You Love Me Tomorrow0000Will You Love Me Tomorrow
92
 
2Safe
Beautiful0000Beautiful
80
 
2Safe
Pleasant Valley Sunday *0000Pleasant Valley Sunday *
61
 
2Safe
Where You Lead0000Where You Lead
51
 
4Bottom Group
Star Collector *0000Star Collector *Duet performance
44
 
9Group performance
Up On The Roof0000Up On The RoofDuet performance
41
 
9Group performance
Take A Giant Step *0000Take A Giant Step *
37
 
4Bottom Group
I'm Into Something Good0000I'm Into Something GoodDuet performance
25
 
9Group performance
Oh No Not My Baby0000Oh No Not My Baby
23
 
7Eliminated
Friday, July 1st, 2011

Final 5 (Now and Then)

Performance Web Rating Result
House Of The Rising Sun0000House Of The Rising Sun
94
 
2Safe
Flat On The Floor0000Flat On The Floor
86
 
2Safe
Unchained Melody0000Unchained Melody
77
 
2Safe
You And I0000You And I
76
 
2Safe
Firebomb *0000Firebomb *
55
 
2Safe
Without You0000Without You
52
 
2Safe
Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood*0000Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood*
50
 
2Safe
Closer To The Edge0000Closer To The Edge
45
 
2Safe
Sky Pilot *0000Sky Pilot *
33
 
7Eliminated
Little Lion Man *0000Little Lion Man *
30
 
7Eliminated
Sunday, July 3rd, 2011

Final 4 (Inspirational / Lieber and Stoller)

Performance Web Rating Result
I (Who Have Nothing)0000I (Who Have Nothing)
85
 
2Safe
Anyway0000Anyway
79
 
2Safe
Love Potion #90000Love Potion #9
63
 
2Safe
Don't Stop Believin'0000Don't Stop Believin'
52
 
2Safe
Trouble0000Trouble
48
 
2Safe
Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me *0000Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me *
46
 
7Eliminated
Kansas City *0000Kansas City *
41
 
7Eliminated
Earth Song0000Earth Song
38
 
2Safe
Monday, July 4th, 2011

Final 3 (Idol's / Jimmy's / Judges' Choice)

Performance Web Rating Result
What Is And What Should Never Be0000What Is And What Should Never Be
85
 
2Safe
I Hope You Dance0000I Hope You Dance
77
 
7Eliminated
Rhiannon0000Rhiannon
70
 
2Safe
Ring Of Fire *0000Ring Of Fire *
60
 
2Safe
Smoke On The Water *0000Smoke On The Water *
54
 
2Safe
Boom Boom Pow *0000Boom Boom Pow *
50
 
2Safe
If I Die Young0000If I Die Young
39
 
7Eliminated
You Oughta Know0000You Oughta Know
36
 
2Safe
Wild One0000Wild One
30
 
7Eliminated
Tuesday, July 5th, 2011

Finale

Performance Web Rating Result
House Of The Rising Sun0000House Of The Rising SunReprise performance
74
 
2Safe
Will You Love Me Tomorrow*0000Will You Love Me Tomorrow*Reprise performance
72
 
7Eliminated
Maybe It Was Memphis0000Maybe It Was Memphis
50
 
2Safe
Oh Well0000Oh Well
45
 
2Safe
Dream Big *0000Dream Big *
45
 
7Eliminated
Medley from 'How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb' *0000Medley from 'How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb' *
41
 
7Eliminated

Camp Should-A-Been – Season Ten Alternate Universe Results

  1. Haley Reinhart
  2. James Durbin
  3. Lauren Alaina
  4. Pia Toscano
  5. Lauren Turner
  6. Jacob Lusk
  7. Scotty McCreery
  8. Casey Abrams
  9. Kendra Chantelle
  10. Paul McDonald
  11. Stefano Langone
  12. Naima Adedapo
  13. Thia Megia

-- The staff of WNTS.com

WhatNotToSing.com copyright © 2007-2020, The WNTS Team.  All rights reserved.  Use of this website implies that you accept our Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy.  American Idol is a registered trademark of 19 TV Ltd.  We are not affiliated in any way with American Idol, Fox Television, FremantleMedia North America, or any of their parent or subsidiary companies.