|#||Season||Episode / Theme||Slot||Contestant||Approval Rating||σ||Result|
"Crocodile Rock", with its distinctive calliope-like organ riff, was Elton John's first #1hit in the U.S. As with most of John's upbeat numbers, it features several big jumps in pitch and requires a very wide range. Only John Stevens in AI3 has attempted this number in the competition, and the results were not pretty (but see its performance page for an explanation of how it rated out as high as a 9).
Even if "Crocodile Rock" had no history on Idol, we would urge contestants to stay far away from it. It contains at least three WhatNotToSing.com deathtraps: a bubblegum song, a highly distinctive vocal by the original artist, and a falsetto. After what happened to Stevens, "Rock" heads our Under No Circumstances Whatsoever list. If you make it to the Final 3, and by some sick joke Clive Davis or one of the judges assigns you this song, we suggest you call in sick.